Consider this: if profit is the only priority, what becomes of everyone else? Does it matter if someone impoverished goes hungry? Does it matter if someone unwell suffers and dies without treatment? Does it matter if someone receives an education, or perishes without one? Does it matter if thousands of people, each with their own hopes and dreams, die unfulfilled? Does anyone even give a damn?
If there’s a profit to be made from planetary destruction, child mortality, and the peddling of violence, then so be it, as long as the coffers keep filling!
Isn’t this sort of profit, made off the back of people’s misery, what they call “Crony Capitalism”?
Capitalism, at its core, is an economic system where private individuals or businesses own capital goods. Goods and services are produced for profit, driven by competition in a free market. Ideally, this fosters innovation and efficiency, benefiting society through lower prices and better products. However, this idealised version is often distorted by something called crony capitalism.
Crony capitalism is a different beast altogether. It’s where this pursuit of profit becomes entangled with close relationships between businesses and the government. Instead of open competition, success is determined by who you know, not what you do. Favouritism, special deals, and regulatory loopholes become the tools of the trade, allowing a select few to amass wealth and power at the expense of everyone else.
This profit-mindedness, when unchecked by ethical considerations, can wreak havoc on society. The relentless drive for profit can lead to businesses cutting corners, exploiting workers, and damaging the environment. The focus becomes solely on maximising returns for a small group of shareholders, while the needs and well-being of the wider population are ignored. For example, industries that are demonstrably harmful, like those producing excessively sugary drinks or highly addictive substances, can thrive under crony capitalism, as long as they are profitable, regardless of the societal cost.
This creates a situation where the vast majority suffers so that a tiny minority can profit. Essential services might be neglected, inequality deepens, and public trust erodes. While profit is undoubtedly important for a healthy economy, it cannot be the only consideration. Ethics, human life, feelings, humanity, and values – these are not mere abstract concepts. They are the very fabric of a just and thriving society. Can we, in good conscience, sacrifice all of these on the altar of profit? Surely, a more balanced approach is needed, one that recognises the importance of profit, but also prioritises the well-being of all members of society.
The Islamic economic system presents a unique model, prioritising ethical considerations and social well-being alongside economic efficiency. It stands in stark contrast to conventional capitalism, particularly the damaging form of crony capitalism, offering a humane alternative grounded in moral principles and social responsibility.
A cornerstone of the Islamic system is the prohibition of riba (usury or interest). This discourages speculative financial activities and fosters investment in real assets and productive enterprises. Instead of profiting solely from lending money, Islamic finance encourages risk-sharing through mechanisms like mudarabah (profit-sharing) and murabaha (cost-plus financing). This promotes genuine economic activity, benefiting society through job creation and the production of goods and services. By avoiding excessive reliance on debt, it also reduces the potential for financial bubbles and crises often associated with interest-based systems.
Unlike crony capitalism, where close ties between businesses and government lead to favouritism and corruption, the Islamic system emphasises fairness, transparency, and open competition. It discourages monopolies and promotes a level playing field for all economic actors. This focus on ethical conduct extends to all aspects of business, prohibiting deceptive practices, hoarding, and other exploitative behaviours. Profit-seeking is not condemned, but it must be pursued within a framework of moral and ethical values. Businesses are expected to consider the impact of their actions on society and the environment, rather than solely focusing on maximising profits at any cost.
Several key features contribute to the humane nature of the Islamic economic system. Zakat, a mandatory form of charity, plays a vital role in wealth redistribution and poverty alleviation. It ensures that wealth circulates within society and that the less fortunate are supported. Sadqa (voluntary charity) and other forms of alms further enhance social safety nets and promote community solidarity.
Moral foundations are paramount in the Islamic economic system. Honesty, trustworthiness, and fairness are considered essential qualities for all economic actors. This creates a culture of trust and cooperation, fostering a more stable and harmonious economic environment.
Fair distribution of wealth is a key objective. While acknowledging that some inequality is inevitable, the Islamic system seeks to minimise disparities and ensure that wealth is not concentrated in the hands of a few.
Crony capitalism, with its inherent corruption and self-dealing, stands in stark contrast to these principles. The pursuit of profit at all costs, regardless of ethical considerations or social impact, leads to widespread inequality, exploitation, and ultimately, economic instability. The Islamic economic system, by prioritising ethical conduct, social justice, and responsible economic activity, offers a more humane and sustainable alternative, addressing the very issues that create the social and economic disasters associated with cronyism.
Suhaib Nadvi
[Email: Contact@Laahoot.com]
Laahoot Digest
Let’s connect on Social Media:
https://www.facebook.com/LaahootDigest
https://x.com/LaaHoot
https://www.youtube.com/@LaaHoot
